blog
Aritcle
Earlier today I ran across an article with the blazing headline "China Rips off Pokemon, Naruto, and Digimon", and being a fan of all things anti-anime, I had to take a look. Central China Television, a state-run broadcasting company, has recently started to air a series called "Dragon Baby". It's an anime about dinosaurs, but supposedly it borrows heavily from the characters and plot devices of such "classic" animes as Pokémon, Naruto, and Digimon.

The heads of the CCTV company showed a lot of gaul on the situation, too. When confronted about this so-called anime rip-off buffet, they responded first by saying that the issue was with the anime's producers and not the broadcasting company (which is very true), and then by letting the public know that they didn't see a problem. Said a spokesman for CCTV: "This is a rip off? What's being called a rip? What's being called a copy? Please think first, then talk."
And you know what? I agree wholeheartedly with CCTV. An anime with regurgitated plots and stock characters with generic personalities that matches the personalities and designs of other characters in other anime serials is...an anime! Everything about the original Japanese products is uninspired, unoriginal, full of plot holes, and borrows so heavily from its genre that if you've seen one anime in a particular genre, you've seen them all. All the Chinese producers are doing with "Dragon Baby" is what every other anime company in Japan does when they create a new series: regurgitate the same clichés that anime created. I'd put my seal of approval on this one and let it go!
Of course, my polarizing views of anime pale in comparison to this next example. Supposedly, in an attempt to create a "domestic anime market" in China, Chinese anime producers have ripped off of other serials before. I went snooping for another one of the animes supposedly ripped off, and I was shocked when I discovered "Soul's Window".
The original article made mention of rip-offs of "Crayon Shin chan" and "5 Centimeters per Second", so I went looking for some examples of these knock-offs. And I certainly found one in the Chinese anime "Soul's Window". This anime isn't just another rock in the Cliché sea that is anime -- "Soul's Window" is an almost frame-for-frame plagiarisation of "5 Centimeters per Second". Apparently it's garnered a lot of hatred from the anime community, but as a writer and storyteller, I have no tolerance for such blatant plagiarism.
Take a look at some images of the Chinese "Soul's Window" and the Japanese "5 Centimeters per Second". "Soul's Window" images are on top, and "5 Centimeters per Second" images are below them:


--------------------------


--------------------------


--------------------------


--------------------------


Shameless, blatant plagairising, isn't it? These are just a few examples of the frame copies between "Soul's Window" and "5 Centimeters per Second". I think what bothers me most is that the producers of this Chinese knock-off couldn't even be bothered with borrowing from the same clichés and nonsense in anime to make something new -- they just had to steal an anime wholesale. What, was following the formula too hard? This is a creative disgrace, no matter how you feel about anime.
If you want to see more frame comparisons between "Soul's Window" and "5 Centimeters per Second", you can find them at the second source link.
[Sources: kotaku.com/5358634/china-rips-off-pokemon-naruto-and-digimon, www.sankakucomplex.com/2009/09/02/souls-window-china-rips-off-5cm-per-second/]
Tags: China anime rip-off plagiarism plagiarising stealing an
Ariticle url: http://my.mmosite.com/blog/2aecbd118ed47523f4132bdc3a275d9c/blog/item/b166b06fde66148c86d783ddea8d8655.html
