blog

Aritcle

digg 3

Anime and MMORPG

Category: Game Industry Game: Default Posted on Feb 04, 2008 3:58 am


These 2 area has become popular things in the world right now.  And we have become the witness on how they are converging.  Even RO was said to have an anime character type.  We have also Talesweaver, Trickster, dan some other 2D graphic anime style graphic.  The influence of anime also can be seen to the 2D side scrolling by adopting the SD (Super Deformed) figure in Maple Story or Ghost Online.  And after the 3D engines becomes better, some games with anime type began to enter the market.  Lunia, Yogurting, Holic Online, DECO, DOMO, and many more.  Not just that, we are waiting for a new MMORPG based on anime itself.  From the legendary anime / manga of Akira Toriyama, comes Dragon Ball Online.

Will adopting the anime graphic style would make MMORPG success?  If that’s the only thing that they adopt, I believe, they won’t.  As we all already know, it will all come back to the game feature.  Surely, that using an anime style graphic will quickly catch the otaku or anime fans attention.  But, again the game feature talk more loudly.

 

Anime vs Non Anime Character

During my research for my thesis about anime manga in my country, I found that there are several things that differentiate the Japanese style with other countries style, and these are what make them popular in all over the world. 

1. Role!

Japanese anime or manga character has a characteristic of a ROLE like in the RPG.  The role that I am talking about is in term of growth.  We watch how Son Goku of Dragon Ball, when he was a little searching for Shen Long Ball, up until he has this little Son Gohan, fighting the Saiyan fellow Vegetta (or Bejita), and when he has to sacrifice himself againts Cell.  And we also watch how he was just a mere strong boy and started to learn the legendary skill Kamehameha, up until he became Super Saiyan, Super Saiyan 2, and Super Saiyan 3.  We watch him grow!  And we got attached by the character.  While on the other side, we know some superheroes but we never watch them grow.  Lately, the publisher start to realize this and try to improve by providing the history or the youth of their superheroes.  But in my opinion, it’s too late for their ‘old’ superheroes.  They should improve them in their ‘new’ superheroes.

This what attach player to most RPG or MMORPG too.  One of the biggest reason why people can stand grinding in an MMORPG, in my opinion, is because they know that in the end of this painful grinding, there will be growth or change in their character.  A higher level, a higher stat, or a new skill.

2. Unique!

Japanese manga or anime character, usually has few or only one strength with many weaknesses.  While on the other hand, other superheroes usually has many strength with only few or one weakness.  Let’s take an example.  Naruto is clumsy, a little bit ‘late’, careless, and many more weaknesses compare to his fellow friends BUT he has a really-really strong will to become Hokage.  While Superman has a superhuman strength, light speed, an infrared capable eyesight, steel body, BUT his weakness is kryptonite.

This condition, is much closer to the real life.  Usually, someone famous is because (only) for his or her few strength, not because of many strength.  David Beckham would be related to soccer skill (well good looking too, I envy but had to admit XD), Tiger Wood with golf skill, Pavarotti with singing skill, Beyonce with sexy singing performance (drool XD), and many more.  Somehow, this pattern, would make someone famous unique!  We can get attached more easily with something that represent us more.  That’s why it is easier to remember Luffy with his Gomu-Gomu skill, Naruto with his Raisengan (or Sexy No Jutsu XD), Ichigo with his blade Zangetsu, or Kira Yamato with Strike Freedom Gundam.  And this uniqueness, what make otaku (like me), like Japanese manga better than any other comic.  While on the other hand, superheroes from other comic industries, is equipped with so many strength and finally made us really confuse about their main strength.  The uniqueness started to blur.  They don’t give any limitation to their superheroes.  The beauty of being limited, is uniqueness.

Upon reading Lean’s comment about being random and being unique, I started to realize that this feature is what makes me playing Diablo for years!  And MMORPG with this feature, will make them playable for quite a long time.  Providing unique feature is not always about being random, but also being limited.  You can not upgrade all field of stat in RO but rather you have to choose in your limited resources, what kind of character that you want to build.  A full support Priest with full VIT n INT, or speed killer Knight with full AGI n STR?

 Now I have mentioned features and pattern that an MMORPG should have.  And I am really looking forward to any MMORPG based on anime theme, that they’re not relying on the brand power, but they really work on the feature, especially these 2 strength that made them popular.

 

Mainstream Anime in MMORPG

When I was writing this article, Paradox(Destruction) is already posting his article about Dragon Ball online.  What a coincidence!   Seriously Paradox, if you read this, I am writing this article even before you post yours!  But I have the same worries as he is.  However, if I have to predict about other mainstream anime title, this is how I will imagine about them.  And here’s what I thought:

 

Naruto

I think the world that created by Masashi Kishimoto is the most potential one to be made as a world of MMORPG.  Imagine being a ninja with so many skill to choose.  Being unique because you are a member of certain family bloodline.  Uchiha or Hyuga and so finally you can see which one is better, Sharingan or Byakugan.  Or maybe you are not from certain famous family but along your adventure, there is one Jinchuriki in your character, like Kyubi!  And I can imagine that you build your castle under Konoha clan, thus having a clan war  with Sunagakure clan.  Or you don’t want to be part of the clan but rather being a missing nin and establish an organization like Akatsuki!  Moreover, you can move in a team mission like the famous Team 7 of Kakashi.  Slaying some monster or thug or even unknown missing nin.  And when you are in the middle of your mission you have suddenly face one of the famous missing nin like Zabusa n Hakku.  Hope Bandai n Shueisha start to consider this title as an MMORPG.

 

One Piece

The world of pirates in One Piece is also potential as an MMORPG.  The skill of every evil fruit is unique.  Even the non evil fruit eater is unique.  I can still remember the funny moment when Luffy was asked why he choose and believe so much in his member.

Luffy: “I can’t play sword, that’s why I have Zorro”

Luffy: “I know nothing about navigation, that’s why I have Nami”

Luffy: “I can’t cook, that’s why I have Sanji”

Luffy: “I know nothing about medic, that’s why I have Chopper”

Luffy: “I’m not good at lying…”

Ussop: “Woi woi woi woi…”

LOL, but that’s what makes you unique Ussop, besides your canon aiming skill XD.

Being unique is very important, so this world already has the preleminary condition met.  Imagine having a voyage to seek the legendary cursed weapon and slay monster and fellow pirate along the way.  You can be pirates or you can choose as navy.  The arc rival of Luffy, Crocodile, is potential as a tough boss.  Your character is a normal one until you found an evil fruit, and you can decide if you want to eat it or not.  Hope Eichiro Oda can consider a license for its title being made as an MMORPG.

 

Bleach

Well in my opinion, this title is also having a potential element to be made as an MMORPG, but it will require much more thought from game developers, compare to the above 2 title.  Indeed each character has unique skill and even weapon.  But everybody is a shinigami.   Game developer has to work on the job or race things before they can implement this title.  Moreover, there are no common skill in this title.  And the skill was always depend on equipment.  Renji with Sabimaru, Ichigo with Zangetsu, and their skill was determined by their Zanpakutou form (Bankai).  Slaying hollow will be fun but with skill limited to equipment only is rather boring in my opinion.  Well I am not hoping too much about this title of Kubo Tite being brought to the MMORPG market.

 

Full Metal Alchemist

This is also a potential world to be created, as each of the alchemist performer has skill that can grow with unique characteristic.  Moreover, this title was owned by the Square Enix, a well known game developer and publisher.  There are element that can diversified characters.   They can design fire element alchemist like Roy Mustang, or nature element alchemist like Edward and Al.  There are monster and chimera. Homonculus can be made as boss.  It’s a good potential world.

 

Universal Century (or any other Gundam Universe)

This is the world and timeline of the first Gundam series.  It is the time when the legendary newtype Amuro Ray with his arc rival Chars Aznable live.  Recently, the new Gundam 00 was told in AD timeline.  Anyway, I was once heard a rumor about a Universal Century Online (http://www.universalcentury.net/index.html).  But this title was make me more worry even compare to the upcoming Dragon Ball Online.  While Dragon Ball still have skill to differentiate each character, has race to consider, and so many monster or enemy to slay, Universal Century basically is about the clash of human principle.  So even the Zaku pilot, is a human that believe in certain principle THAT unfortunately different from other people piloting Gundam.  So who’s gonna be the monster?  All the Zaku type?  Moreover, what about the skill?  Every gundam pilot has skill growth but the Gundam itself doesn’t have any evolving skill!  They’re just changing the equipment and armaments.  Or sometimes, they even change the machine completely.  Look at the Gundam Seed series.  Kira Yamato was riding Aile Strike with weapon system,  and later change to Freedom Gundam.  It’s completely different Gundam.  And in GSD, Strike Freedom is also a very different Gundam compare to the previous one, even if the name is nearly the same.  So I really doubt the outcome of this online title if they are to be implemented as MMORPG.  Maybe they can implement it as MMO mecha simulation, but how are they going to accommodate the pilot skill growth?  Well although I doubt this title, but who knows?  We’re still waiting for the product launching anyway.

Well anime is anime, they have their own characteristic to be success.  MMORPG is another thing, feature (and marketing and some other aspects) is the key success.  So relying only on the title popularity, can't guarantee the success of the game.

 

comments ( 16 )

lozen
Post Time : Feb 12,2008 12:35 am
thats wat they did when ps2 released DragonballOne pieceNaruto or DON(not online just console)

they mixed ONE PIECE,DRAGONBALL and NARUTO characters and u can choose ur characters and fight

i think thats quite a good idea actually but of course deciding on classes,race and abilities will be very confusing
LordDrathan
Post Time : Feb 11,2008 3:50 pm
i don't think they should be a story just war and quest (or mission in there case) but to make my one shinigami or in my case vizard) that would be hot, and to make my own naruto char that would be hot to. oh hell it would be hot to mix up anime in an all out anime brawl(ok mybe went a little over board) lol ;)
spikeyman1891
Post Time : Feb 06,2008 8:11 pm
also on the naruto thing. dont thing ud be able to make another uchiha because madara,sasuke, and itachi are the last of the clan if you wanna stick to the story...
spikeyman1891
Post Time : Feb 06,2008 7:08 pm
lol should of went over it before i posted. sry for the missing commas n stuff
spikeyman1891
Post Time : Feb 06,2008 7:06 pm
bleach would be tough for with the thousand of people that come in as new shinigami there would have to be completely distinct and unique zanpaktous. not everyone will like having the same weapon as theyre friend sure they can have the same katana but when they release it it will have to be different same as when they get to the point of reaching Bankai. would be cool though if you were later given the choice of going vaizard or arrancar(but hat being if that person chose to be a hollow). a bleach mmo i would totally join but the exreme need for everyone to be absolutly unique will be very tough. also it will be a pain when somone will get a zanpaktou they dont like. for example character A's zanpaktou releases into a huge great sword that releases energy similiar to getsuga tenshou. and Character B has a zanpaktou that releases into spear that has the ability to use water like energy Kaizen's zanpaktou(watch the newer episodes to understand). people will be jealous of what others recieved and will want the same or lead to disputes that one may be to over powering then the other especially if pvp is implemented. things like this would rise and it will inevitably be very strenuous to the dev's. Bleach is a good concept but way too complicated to create.
Dexcross
Post Time : Feb 05,2008 9:47 pm
@Radu_Avr:
^^ Thanks for the feedback, I will try to improve my grammar in my next articles. English is not my mother language, but I won't make it as an excuse. Still trying to get used to proper grammar. But I am glad you enjoy the article.

@lozen:
Yeah I think Bleach can be a good action rpg.

@Dragonek:
I dun think it's an official one. There are no sign of Shueisha or Bandai copyrights in that page, and I'm pretty sure if they decide to bring it as an MMORPG, they will publish them widely, because Naruto is one of the major title that they have. I think it's more like fans creation, such as Naruto version of DOTA (Defence Of The Ancient), a popular mod of Warcraft III.
lozen
Post Time : Feb 05,2008 5:52 pm
are there any trailers on it?
Dragonek
Post Time : Feb 05,2008 2:41 pm
Hello.

You said about Naruto MMORPG i found few weeks ago one

http://www.narutool.com.cn/index/Index.aspx

U can check it if u want.
lozen
Post Time : Feb 05,2008 5:45 am
im definitely looking forward to an anime made into a mmorpg title especially bleach and naruto

im imagining bleahc's combat to be extremely catastrophic which will be very visually spectacular( if u see the anime theres alot of area destruction)

as for naruto it will definitely be a big world....1st choose ur country then ur village then ur clan then ur master and missions and training journeys and so on and so on...settle diplomatic matters,kill criminals ...just so much to do

im just wondering if current technology can handle such features though
Radu_Avr
Post Time : Feb 05,2008 1:18 am
Well. I think it's a nice article, a very nice one indeed. But, I've seen so many grammar errors there that made me think, "You need to improve your grammar, mate." Honestly, it wasn't that bad but there were some that ticked me off. Your ideas that you wanted to pass on, your message, were all fabulous. Truth is, for its grammar, I wouldn't want to recommend this article. However, your way of explaining Anime MMORPGs was really amazing, and I truly enjoyed it. I'm awaiting your next articles, but only if they have better grammar. Goodluck!
Dexcross
Post Time : Feb 05,2008 12:46 am
@lean:
LOL I'm quite surprised that anyone beside me can actually love it, but I'm glad that you do. Ah, I forgot that Saint Seiya is also a good potential title to be made.

@cesarsuki:
I would say that it depend on the feature. Remember that Ragnarok Online is based on comic by Lee Myoung Jin. And many people never knew that this comic exist, but they play the game. So if the game feature is designed well, I believe, even the market that never knew about the title, they will play it.

@Layce:
In my opinion, MMORPG is very different from movie or comic or anime in terms of story. Because even the publisher start to give story quest to most of the MMORPG, however the story is like omake to any existing story. RO is one example. Another one is Yulgang: Scion of Fate, it is an MMORPG based on a comic about a hero called Han Bi Kwang, but the story in the game is very much different from the comic. So I believe there will never be any spoiler. What really matter, once again... is feature.
Layce
Post Time : Feb 04,2008 10:11 pm
Honestly I dont really like the idea of making an anime into mmo, unless the company that makes it really follow the original idea and not spoiling it, because it is like from anime to movie, or game to movie, example the resident evil, it is a real spoiler! Mostly now the movie industry is aiming to make their movie from games or novels, and sadly most of the movie is not following the original and they change it with their own idea, but actually their idea is not that good, or should I say, sucks...I like animes very much, and those anime that u listed almost all I have watched, they are great! But if anyone that make them into mmo and spoil it like the movie now, I rather they not making any of them into mmo...
cesarsuki
Post Time : Feb 04,2008 9:46 pm

My 2 cents is that it depends largely on the target market, for example I have never seen Naruto or Bleach. However, I would play Dragon Ball online, but newer generations don't know who the characters are much less the story. It is like making a mmo for a movie, some people saw it some don't.


lean
Post Time : Feb 04,2008 7:25 pm
lol I think Dexcross's avatar is funny and I love it
I agree with you, unlike American superheroes, Japanese anime's character is often a normal man with strong will (such as Naruto and Saint Seiya). So they can grow up rapidly and that's what attract me.
Another Anime I'd like to be MMORPG: Saint Seiya. I like the armor there and I believe it can be a good MMORPG with various equipments.
Dexcross
Post Time : Feb 04,2008 2:19 pm
XD
If you read a manga or watch the anime called Eyeshield 21, you will notice that it is the face of Daimon school American Football team mascot, the Devilbat. I like Hiruma and this is his team mascot, that's why I wear it as my avatar ^^. Ugly indeed, but you have to watch the anime. It's hilarious.
And if you ever watch Gundam Seed Destiny, you will also notice that the uniform being used by my avatar is the uniform of ZAFT. For me, it's the coolest uniform in anime.
MaX4You3LoL
Post Time : Feb 04,2008 8:50 am
Your face are UgLy~~ XD